Understanding and Combating Workplace Bullying
Statistics reveal a troubling picture: approximately 30% of U.S. workers have experienced bullying at work. This widespread issue affects more than just the individuals involved; it can also have a negative impact on the workplace environment, leading to decreased productivity, increased absenteeism, and higher turnover rates.
While the term bullying often elicits images of schoolyard taunts or shoving in the hallway, workplace bullying is a persistent pattern of mistreatment from others in the workplace, often driven by a perpetrator’s need for control. It can include tactics such as humiliation as well as verbal, nonverbal, psychological, and/or physical abuse. This type of aggression is particularly deceptive because it is often subtle, hidden in the fabric of the organizational culture, and it can be devastating to the target’s mental and physical health. Bullying is not about each isolated incident; it’s about an ongoing pattern of behavior with severe consequences for both the target and the broader workplace culture.
Health Impacts of Bullying
The effects of bullying extend far beyond emotional distress, which alone can cause mental health challenges such as anxiety and depression. What many don’t consider, however, are the serious physical health problems that can arise, including chronic stress-related conditions like hypertension and cardiovascular issues. The prolonged stress from being in a toxic work environment can lead to debilitating conditions like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and other stress-related disorders.
Economic and Organizational Consequences
The organizational repercussions of bullying cannot be ignored. They can impact team dynamics, productivity, and even the bottom line. Organizations with high rates of workplace bullying face high turnover, absenteeism, and decreased employee engagement. Moreover, they may also face legal and reputational risks if bullying claims escalate.
To illustrate these points, let’s examine a real-world case that highlights the complexities of managing workplace bullying at high levels of leadership.
Case Study: Workplace Bullying at the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP)
Background: This case involved Eric Lander, the director of the OSTP and a Presidential Cabinet member. Despite his impressive background, Lander’s tenure at OSTP was marred by reports of bullying.
Incidents: Employees reported a range of behaviors from Lander, including:
- Mood swings and demeaning behavior behind closed doors, contrasting with his positive public persona.
- Public humiliation of staff, including yelling at them in front of peers.
- Systematic undermining of colleagues, particularly targeting female staff, which left many feeling traumatized.
- Violation of the White House’s Safe and Respectful Workplace Policy.
Organizational Response: Formal complaints eventually led to an internal investigation. Despite initial resistance, the investigation acknowledged the credible evidence of Lander’s disrespectful interactions with staff. Corrective actions were discussed, although implementation was gradual and met with skepticism regarding its effectiveness.
Outcome: The case concluded with Lander’s resignation, prompted by the pressure of upcoming exposés and internal reviews. While this ultimately resolved the issue, it also highlighted the challenges in managing such behavior at high levels of leadership and the need for more robust enforcement of workplace policies.
Lessons Learned: This case underscores the importance of taking employee complaints seriously and the need for institutions to enforce their own policies consistently as well as the potential consequences of unchecked power dynamics within organizations and the importance of leadership setting behavioral standards at all levels.
The complexity of addressing workplace bullying, especially when involving high-ranking officials, demonstrates the need for clear policies, active enforcement, and a culture that does not tolerate bullying in any form. There will always be a need for vigilance and proactive management to ensure a respectful and safe working environment for all employees.
With these insights, how can organizations prevent and respond to workplace bullying? And what resources should be available to those who are being bullied or witness an incident?
Strategies for Prevention and Intervention
Proactive prevention and robust intervention strategies are essential in combating workplace bullying:
- Clear Policies and Communication: Develop clear guidelines that define bullying behaviors, and outline the procedures for handling complaints. These policies must be communicated effectively to all employees.
- Google’s comprehensive anti-bullying policies are included in their employee code of conduct. It clearly defines what constitutes bullying and outlines a process for reporting incidents. Google conducts regular training sessions to ensure employees understand these policies and feel empowered to speak up.
- Training and Awareness Programs: Regular training should be held to raise awareness about workplace bullying and its effects. These sessions should be holistic, covering everything from how to identify bullying to how to report instances of bullying to how bullying can impact the whole organization. To be effective, they need to educate from all perspectives, not just the target or the bully alone, but how bystanders and leadership should intervene as well.
- Workplace bullying or harassment training can come in a variety of formats. The important part is that it is comprehensive, addressing prevention, intervention, and the applicable laws for that organization. Sessions should be accessible, easy to understand, and engaging. Some topics that may be covered could include bystander intervention and implicit bias training.
- Supportive Reporting Structures: Encourage a culture where employees feel safe to report bullying without fear of retaliation by establishing multiple, confidential channels for reporting inappropriate behavior.
- After recognizing that they had a problem with employee retention, Intel set up an anonymous helpline called the “WarmLine” where employees can report bullying or harassment. This system ensures confidentiality and is overseen by case managers from Intel’s Global Diversity and Inclusion team who are trained to handle such reports sensitively and discreetly. The results reflect the success of the program: Intel now has an 82% save rate (meaning employees did not leave the company after filing a complaint), and they even met their diversity goals two years ahead of schedule.
- Regular Assessments: Continuously assess the workplace culture through surveys and feedback mechanisms to detect any signs of bullying and to evaluate the effectiveness of existing policies and interventions.
- Zappos regularly collects paragraphs of positive and negative feedback from employees to maintain a positive corporate culture, which is then compiled into what is called the “Culture Book”.
- Promoting a Positive Work Culture: Cultivate an environment that values respect, diversity, and inclusion. Encourage employees through recognition and reward programs that align with these values.
- Adobe is well-known for their inclusive workplace culture, which includes unconscious bias training, mentorship opportunities, and resource groups as well as a substantial employee recognition program to show employees that they are valued. One of their core values is “Be genuine,” which further allows employees to feel a sense of belonging within the company. These initiatives have led to Adobe being listed consistently as a Fortune “100 Best Companies to Work For” among other awards.
Correcting workplace bullying is more than simply responding to incidents as they arise. It must be a strategic approach that includes educating the workforce, creating a supportive environment, and fostering a culture of respect and inclusion. By taking proactive steps, organizations can prevent the impacts of bullying and create a healthier, more productive work environment for all employees.
How does your organization currently handle incidents of workplace bullying? Are there clear policies and reporting structures in place? What role do you believe workplace culture plays in either enabling or discouraging bullying behaviors? How can this culture be shaped by both employees and leadership?
Let us share experiences. Leave a comment below, send me an email, or find me on Twitter.
